Operational Impact of Horizontal and Vertical Alignment of Two-Lane Highways

Abstract

The Highway Capacity Manual (HCM) defines the level-of-service criteria for two-lane highways based on three performance measures: average travel speed (ATS), percent time spend following (PTSF) and percent of free-flow speed (PFFS). The performance measures are affected by the lack of passing opportunities, which is quantified through adjustment factors depending on the percentage of no passing zones. Passing zones are provided where available sight distance is greater than the minimum passing sight distance; and their length and frequency depend mainly on the physical constrains and cost limitations. HCM current evaluation of traffic performance excludes horizontal alignment variations, which could produce more or less sinuous alignments and thus affect potentially to both average travel speed and percentage time spent following. Moreover, HCM considers terrain type rather than the actual vertical profile, which could overestimate or underestimate the expected traffic performance depending on how accurately the roadway was adapted to the terrain. The objective of the research is to analyze the relationship between highway horizontal alignment, characterized by curvature change rate (CCR), highway vertical alignment, characterized by the gradient change rate, and traffic performance, based on ATS and PTSF. For the research, 25 Spanish two-lane rural highways were selected. Horizontal geometry was obtained from Google Earth using an azimuth-based restitution program. CCR was calculated and used to identify homogenous segments. Vertical alignment was recreated from GPS data. The sample included 112 homogeneous segments and 451 passing zones. After the geometry-based characterization, 20 homogeneous segments were introduced and simulated in the TWOPAS simulation model. TWOPAS was previously calibrated and validated with passing maneuvers data from Spanish highways. Traffic conditions (directional traffic volume, directional split and percentage of heavy vehicles) were varied. The analysis of the simulation results provided models of PTSF and ATS depending on CCR and gradient change rate, among other parameters. The results of this research will help highway designers and practitioners to predict operational performance based on CCR, type of gradient and expected hourly traffic volume, and could be used as management and design criteria.

Keywords

Two-lane Highways ; Traffic operation ; Microsimulation ; Geometric design ; Horizontal alignment ; Vertical alignment ; ATS ; PTSF ; Follower density

References

1. Al-Kaisy and Durbin, 2008 A. Al-Kaisy, C. Durbin; Evaluating new methodologies for estimating performance on two-lane highways; Canadian Journal of Civil Engineering, 35 (8) (2008), pp. 777–785
2. Al-Kaisy, 2008 A. Al-Kaisy, S. Karjala; Indicators of Performance on Two-Lane Rural Highways: Empirical Investigation; Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2071 (2008), pp. 87–97
3. Van As, 2006 Van As, S.C. (2006). South African Highway Capacity Research.
4. Brilon, 1997 W. Brilon, F. Weiser; Forschungsbericht “Ermittlung von Q-V Diagrammen für zweistreifige Strassen ausserhalb geschlossener Ortschaften,” Bonn; Germany: Forschung Strassenbau und Strassenverkehrstechnik. (1997)
5. Brilon and Weiser, 2006 W. Brilon, F. Weiser; Two-Lane Rural Highways: The German Experience. (2006)
6. Transportation Research Record:, 1988 Transportation Research Record:; Journal of the Transportation Research Board (1988), pp. 38–47
7. Forschungsgesellschaft, 2015 Forschungsgesellschaft für Strassen und Verkehrswesen. (2015). Handbuch für die Bemessung von Strassenverkehrsanlagen (HBS Edition 2015) . Koeln, Germany.
8. Forschungsgesellschaft, 2013 Forschungsgesellschaft für Strassen und Verkehrswesen . (2013). Richtlinien für die Anlage von Landstraßen , Koeln, Germany.
9. Hashim, 2011 I.H. Hashim, T.A. Abdel-Wahed; Evaluation of performance measures for rural two-lane roads in Egypt; Alexandria Engineering Journal, 50 (3) (2011), pp. 245–255
10. Llorca et al., 2014 Llorca, C., Moreno, A.T., Valencia-Alaix, V. and Garcia, A. (2014). Daytime and Nighttime Following Behavior on Monitored Two-Lane Rural Road. In 93rd Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board .
11. Luttinen et al., 2003 Luttinen, R.T., Dixon, M. and Washburn, S.S. (2003). Two-Lane Highway Analysis in HCM2000, Ministerio de Fomento (1999). Instrucción de Carreteras 3.1 IC: Trazado,.
12. Moreno, 2015 Moreno, A.T. (2015). Análisis de la Funcionalidad del Tráfico en Carreteras Convencionales en función de la Localización y Características de sus Zonas de Adelantamiento. PhD Thesis, Universitat Politècnica de València. Available at: https://riunet.upv.es/handle/10251/49618.
13. Moreno et al., 2015 Moreno, A.T., Llorca, C., Orón-Orón, J.M. and Garcia, A. (2015). Characterization of Passing Zones based on Curvature Change Rate: Operational Impact. In 5th International Symposium on Highway Geometric Design . Vancouver, Canada.
14. Moreno et al., 2016 Moreno, A.T., Llorca, C., Washburn, S.S., Bessa, J.E. and Garcia, A. (2016). Effect of Average Passing Zone Length on Spanish Two-Lane Highways Traffic Performance. In 95th Annual Meeting of the Transportation Research Board .
15. Moreno et al., 2014 A.T. Moreno, C. Llorca, T. Sayed, A. Garcia; Field Evaluation of Traffic Performance Measures for Two-Lane Highways in Spain; Transportation Research Circular, E-C190 (2014), pp. 71–87
16. Moreno et al., 2013 A.T. Moreno, C. Llorca, A. Garcia, A.M. Perez-Zuriaga; Operational Effectiveness of Passing Zones depending on their Length and Traffic Volume; Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board, 2395 (2013), pp. 57–65
17. Oregon, 2010 Oregon Department of Transportation (2010). Modeling Performance Indicators on Two-Lane Rural. Highways: The Oregon Experience.
18. Penmetsa et al., 2015 P. Penmetsa, I. Ghosh, S. Chandra; Evaluation of Performance Measures for Two-Lane Intercity Highways under Mixed Traffic Conditions; Journal of Transportation Engineering (2015), pp. 1–7
19. Polus and Cohen, 2009 A. Polus, M. Cohen; Theoretical and Empirical Relationships for the Quality of Flow and for a New Level of Service on Two-Lane Highways; Journal of Transportation Engineering, 135 (6) (2009), pp. 380–385
20. Transportation, 2010 Transportation Research Board. (2010). Highway Capacity Manual, Transportation Research Board. Weiser, F. et al., 2011. Verkehrstechnische Bemessung von Landstraßen— Weiterentwicklung der. Verfahren.
21. Wikiloc, 2015 Wikiloc. (2015). Wikiloc: Trails of the World. Available at: http://www.wikiloc.com/wikiloc/home.do [Accessed May 2015].