2+1-roads Recent Swedish Capacity and Level-of-Service Experience

Abstract

The first Swedish 2+1 median barrier road was opened in 1998. The concept was to retrofit the standard existing two-lane 13 m paved width cross-section at 90 and 110 kph posted speed limit without widening. This design has one continuous lane in each direction, a middle lane changing direction every one to three kilometres with a median barrier separating the two traffic directions. Today over 2 700 km 2+1 median barrier roads are opened for traffic. AADT’s vary from some 3 000 to 20 000 with an average just below 10 000 nowadays normally with 100 kph. The concept has lately been enhanced also to cover the existing 9 m paved width cross-section. The design concept is the same from a driver’s viewpoint, one continuous lane in each direction with a middle lane changing direction and a separating median barrier. This is created by introducing a continuous median barrier and adding overtaking lanes within an overtaking strategy. The differences are the existence of 1+1-sections, less overtaking opportunities and a slightly more narrow cross-section. Some 15 projects are opened. The purpose of this paper is to summarize present knowledge on level-of-service issues as they are presented in Swedish design and assessment guidelines and to give an overview of field measurements and theoretical analytical and simulation studies supporting the recommendations.

Keywords

2+1-roads ; capacity ; level of service

References

1. Bergh and Carlsson, 1999 Bergh, T. and Carlsson, A. 1999. 2+1 roads with and without cable barriers – speed performance.
2. Bergh and Carlsson, 2005 Bergh, T. and Carlsson, A. 2005. 2+1 cable barrier roads – a Swedish success story. IHSGD. Chicago.
3. Bergqvist and Runn, 2014 Bergqvist, J. and Runn, J. 2014. Hastighetsflödessamband för glesa 2+1-vägar. Exjobb, Linköpings universitet. http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:750088/FULLTEXT01.pdf.
4. Brewer et al., 2012 Brewer, M., Venglar, S., Fitzpatrick, K., Ding, L. and Park, B.J. 2012. Super 2 highways in texas: Operational and safety characteristics. Transportation Research Record.
5. Brewer et al., 2011 Brewer, M.A., Venglar, S.P. and Ding, L. 2011. Operational characteristics of super 2 highways in Texas. Transportation Research Record.
6. Carlsson, 1999 Carlsson, A. 1999. Utvärdering 2+1 halvårsrapport 2, VTI Notat 53. Linköping: VTI.
7. Carlsson, 2009 Carlsson, A. 2009. Evaluation of 2+1-roads with cable barrier, Final report. . VTI Rapport 636A. Linköping: VTI. https://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:670552/FULLTEXT01.pdf.
8. Carlsson, 2014 Carlsson, A. 2014. Trafic performane on E4 Gävle-Noran. PM (in Swedish). Linköping.
9. Carlsson and Brüde, 2003 Carlsson, A. and Brüde, U. 2003. Evaluation of alternative 13 m roads- Half year report 2002:1 (in Swedish). VTI Notat 9-2003. Linköping: VTI.
10. Carlsson et al., 2013 Carlsson, A., Wiklund, M., Olstam, J. and Tapani, A. 2013. Metod för beräkning av fördröjningar på vägavsnitt utan omkörningsmöjlighet. VTI notat 2-2013. Linköping: VTI. http://www.vti.se/sv/publikationer/metod-for-berakning-av-fordrojningar-pa-vagavsnitt-utan-omkorningsmojlighet/.
11. Catbagan and Nakamura, 2006 Catbagan, J.L. and Nakamura, H. 2006. Evaluation of performance measures for two-lane expressways in Japan. Transportation Research Record.
12. Olstam and Carlsson, 2014 Olstam, J. and Carlsson, A. 2014. Kapitel 3 - Landsvägar. In: WESTMAN, F. (ed.) TRVMB Kapacitet och framkomlighetseffekter. Borlänge: Trafikverket.
13. Olstam et al., 2013 Olstam, J., Carlsson, A. and Yahya, M.-R. 2013. Hastighetsflödessamband för svenska typvägar - Förslag till reviderade samband baserat på TMS-mätningar från 2009-2011. VTI rapport 784. Linköping: VTI. http://www.vti.se/sv/publikationer/pdf/hastighetsflodessamband-for-svenska-typvagar---forslag-till-reviderade-samband-baserat-pa-tms-matningar-fran-2009-2011.pdf.
14. Robertson and Tapani, 2009 Robertson, K. and Tapani, A. 2009. Hastighet-flödessamband för mötesfria landsvägsutformningar. VTI notat 18-2009. Linköping. http://www.vti.se/sv/publikationer/pdf/hastighet-flodessamband-for-motesfria-landsvagsutformningar.pdf.
15. Strömgren, 2010 Strömgren, P. 2010. Konfiguration omkörningsfält 2+1,-Optimering av flöde/hastighet/omkörningsbar längd, Version 0.5 2010-06-28. Stockholm: Movea Trafikkonsult AB.
16. Tapani, 2005 Tapani, A. 2005. Versatile model for simulation of rural road traffic. Transportation Research Record.
17. Trafik, 2014a Trafik verket 2014a. Kapitel 4 Tillgänglighet, Effektsamband för transportsystemet - Bygg om eller bygg nytt. Version 2014-04-01. Borlänge: Trafikverket. http://www.trafikverket.se/PageFiles/155466/04_kapitel_4_tillganglighet.pdf.
18. Trafikverket2014b., 2014b Trafikverket 2014b. Råd för Vägars och gators utformning. Publikationsnummer 2012:180. Borlänge: Trafikverket. http://online4.ineko.se/trafikverket/Product/Detail/43670.
19. Trafikverket2014c., 2014c Trafikverket 2014c. TRVMB Kapacitet och framkomlighetseffekter - Trafikverkets metodbeskrivning för beräkning av kapacitet och framkomlighetseffekter i vägtrafikanläggningar, TRV 2013:64343. Borlänge: Trafikverket.
20. Vadeby and Forsman, 2010 Vadeby, A. and Forsman, Å. 2010. Utvärdering av nya hastighetsgränssystemet - Effekter på hastigheter, Etapp 1, VTI notat. 14-2010. Linköping: VTI.
21. Wiklund et al., 2015 Wiklund, M., Carlsson, A., Eriksson, O., Olstam, J. and Tapani, A. 2015. Effects of desired speeds for queuing and delay on single-lane road segments. Transportmetrica A: Transport Science , 11, 716-728.
22. Vägverket, 2005 Vägverket 2005. Regeringsuppdrag om hastighetsgränserna på vägarna, VV publikation 2005:100. Borlänge: Vägverket.