Evaluating the Service Quality in Multi-modal Transport Networks

Abstract

The German Highway Capacity Manual HBS (Handbuch fuer die Bemessung von Strassenverkehrsanlagen, FGSV 2015) like other Highway Capacity Manuals provides a collection of methods for evaluating the Level of Service for single road facilities, i.e. a particular network element like a road segment, a ramp, or an intersection. The Level of Service of single road facilities (LOS) is derived from the volume capacity ratio, the delay time or the traffic density.

In addition to the HBS the German guidelines provide a complementary Guideline for Integrated Network Planning RIN (Richtlinien für die integrierte Netzgestaltung, FGSV 2008) which is used for categorising transport networks and for evaluating the service quality in multi-modal networks. Here the LOS refers to entire journeys, i.e. to origin-destination-pairs. The most important indicator for evaluating the service quality of a particular od-pair is the direct speed (= direct distance / journey time). Journey time and the resulting direct speed include not only the in-vehicle time but also access and egress times which can reduce the speed of the entire journey significantly, especially in public transport. Additional indictors evaluation the directness and the travel time ratio of competing modes complement the set of indicators for evaluating the service quality. For each indicator the guideline provides evaluations functions for the service levels A to F which depend on the direct distance between origin and destination. This reflects the fact that speeds typically increase with longer distances while detour factor and travel time ratio decreases.

The paper summarizes the approach of the guideline for evaluating the service quality and presents experience with the evaluation scheme collected in various applications covering car and public transport networks. It shows how the evaluation results can be used to recognize shortcomings in the network not only on the level of od-pairs but also to identify critical network elements. Finally the paper explains how the two guidelines HBS and RIN are connected.

Keywords

service quality ; multi-modal networks ; evaluation function

References

1. ADAC, 2010 ADAC, 2010. EuroTest 2010: Testing local public transport. [Online] Available at: http://www.eurotestmobility.eu/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Local-Public-Transport_Results.pdf [Accessed 10 10 2015].
2. Austroads, 2015 Austroads, 2015. Level of Service Metrics (for Network Operations Planning). Sydney: Austroads Ltd.
3. Bennecke et al., 2011 Bennecke, A., Friedrich, B., Friedrich, M. & Lohmiller, J., 2011. Time-dependent service quality of network sections. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences , Volume 16, pp. 364-373.
4. Buthe and Kotzagiorgi, 2014 Buthe, B. & Kotzagiorgi, S., 2014. Raumwirksamkeitsanalyse auf Basis der Richtlinien für integrierte Netzgestaltung (RIN) im Schienenverkehr (Spatial effectiveness analysis rail traffic based on the guidelines for integrated network design). Straßenverkehrstechnik , 12.
5. Dowling et al., 2008 Dowling, R. et al., 2008. Multimodal level of service analysis for urban streets. Washington(D.C.): Transportation Research Board.
6. Friedrich et al., 2010 Friedrich, M., Schlaich, J. & Schleupen, G., 2010. Bewertung des OEPNV aus Kundensicht. Methodik des ADAC-OEPNV-Tests in europaeischen Grossstaedten (The customers point of view on public transport). Internationales Verkehrswesen , 12, pp. 11-16.
7. HBS, 2015 HBS, 2015. Handbuch fuer die Bemessung von Strassenverkehrsanlagen HBS (German Highway Capacity Manual). Cologne: Forschungsgesellschaft fuer Strassenverkehrsanlagen.
8. RIN, 2008 RIN, 2008. Richtlinien fuer die integrierte Netzgestaltung RIN (German Guideline for Integrated Network Planning). Cologne: Forschungsgesellschaft fuer Strassen- und Verkehrswesen.
9. Transportation Research Board, 2010 Transportation Research Board, 2010. Highway Capacity Manual 2010. Washington D.C.: Transportation Research Board.
10. Transportation Research Board, 2013 Transportation Research Board, 2013. Transit Capacity and Quality of Service Manual. 3rd Edition ed. Washington D.C.(D.C.): Transportation Research Board.